Skip to content
Teralba Industries Logo Square
1300 20 70 20
sales@teralba.com
Quote Request
Login
or
Register
Search
  • Home
  • Products
    Heat Exchangers
    Dimpleflo Tube Heat Exchangers
    Dimpleflo Double Tube Heat Exchangers
    • Industrial (Monotube) Double Pipe Heat Exchangers
    • Sludge (Monotube) Double Pipe Heat Exchangers
    • Sanitary (Monotube) Double Tube Heat Exchangers
    • Winery Must Chilling & Ferment Heating
    • Waste Heat (Energy) Recovery Heat Exchangers
    Dimpleflo Multitube
    • Industrial Shell & Tube Heat Exchangers
    • Industrial Double Tube Sheet Heat Exchangers
    • CIP Heater
    • Sanitary Shell & Tube Heat Exchangers
    • Sanitary Double Tube Sheet Heat Exchanger
    Dimpleflo Multichannel
    • Sanitary Tri Tube Heat Exchangers
    COILFLO HEAT EXCHANGERS
    • Industrial Coilflo Heat Exchanger
    • Sanitary Coilflo Heat Exchanger
    ACCU-THERM PLATE HEAT EXCHANGERS
    • Accu-Therm Plate Heat Exchangers (Gasketed)
    • Accu-Therm Plate Heat Exchangers (Brazed)
    SCRAPED SURFACE HEAT EXCHANGERS
    TEMP-PLATE IMMERSION HEAT EXCHANGERS
    Processing Systems
    Food and Beverage Processing Systems
    • Thermpro HTST Pasteuriser/ Steriliser
    • Thermpro Steam/ Water Heaters
    • Thermpro Chocolate Melters
    • VinPro Fermentation Pressure Vessels
    Industrial Processing Systems
    Stainless Steel Fabrication
    DIMPLE PROFILE ADVANTAGE
  • Applications
    FOOD & BEVERAGE Heat Exchangers
    • Pasteurisers for Yoghurt & Cultures
    • Vegetables
    • Fruits
    • Beverages
    • Prepared Foods
    • Vegetable Oils
    PHARMACEUTICAL HEAT EXCHANGERS
    • Cosmetics
    • Water for Injection (WFI) & Laboratory
    • Medicinal
    ENVIRONMENTAL HEAT EXCHANGERS
    • Sterilisation of Environmental Waste Streams
    • Thermal Hydrolysis for Sewage Treatment
    • Pasteurisation of Sludge
    • Wastewater – Energy Recovery
    • Anaerobic Digestion (AD) Biogas
    • Biodiesel
    • Bioethanol
    INDUSTRIAL HEAT EXCHANGERS
    • Palm oil
    • Fine chemicals
    • Solvents
    • Petrochemicals
    • Process Water (Chlorination)
    • Paints & Coatings
    • Fertilizers
    • Oils & Lubricants
    • Cleaning & Detergents
    • Energy Storage
    • Heavy industry (Explosives, Mining, Energy, Oil Refining)
  • Services
    • Heat Exchanger Assessments
    • Installation & Commissioning
    • Maintenance
    • Spare Parts
  • About Us
    • Company Vision
    • Company Profile
    • Careers at Teralba
    • Quality Standards
    • Environmental Awareness
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Newsletter
    • Downloads
    • Videos
  • Contact

WHAT’S THE BEST HEAT EXCHANGER? PLATE & FRAME OR TUBULAR

  • Stan Baker & StephenG
  • January 31, 2023
WHAT’S THE BEST HEAT EXCHANGER? PLATE & FRAME OR TUBULAR

In our 35 years of manufacturing tube and plate heat exchangers at Teralba Industries, we are often asked how plate heat exchangers compare to tubular units. So we have sought to provide a transparent assessment of the Pros and Cons of both types.

EFFICIENCY. 

PHE,s are typically more efficient than tube-in-tube heat exchangers as the deep chevrons on the heat transfer plates create significant turbulence and, therefore, a high heat transfer coefficient. That said, recent advances in tubular heat exchanger technologies, such as deep dimples or corrugations on the inner and outer tubes, to radically increase turbulence have narrowed the gap.

VISCOUS PRODUCTS

This is one area where tube heat exchangers outperform plate heat exchangers every time. The large cross-sectional area of tubular heat exchangers means that viscous slurries, particulate-laden fluids, and non-Newtonian products can be heated or cooled easily. Products such as dips, chutney, fruit yoghurt and, in industrial environments, sewerage; can be heated or cooled without blockages.

PHE,s can only tolerate clear fluids or, at best, very small particles and low-viscosity liquids.

SIZE/FOOTPRINT

Plate Heat Exchangers usually occupy a much smaller footprint than tube heat exchangers. Depending on the application and heat transfer area required, a tube HE with horizontal tubes may take up to 5 or 5 times the floor area of a PHE. However, in some applications where drainability is unimportant, be mounted vertically to minimise footprint size.

HYGIENE/DRAINABLE

By their inherent design, Plate PHE,s won’t drain or are difficult to drain, especially on multi-pass configurations. Tubular heat exchangers with dimpled tubing can be configured to be completely free draining. Hence their use in the pharmaceutical industry.

MAINTENANCE 

Plate exchangers use a peripheral gasket and port hole gasket to seal each heat exchanger plate from the next. These gaskets need replacing periodically. EPDM or VITON gaskets would be replaced on high-temperature applications every 12 – 36 months, depending on the application. The heat transfer plates are typically 0.5mm or 0.6mm thick stainless steel, compared to 1.6mm – 4mm thick tube walls. Tubular HE,s will mostly outlast a plate unit. Tube heat exchangers usually have gaskets exclusively on the inlet and outlet connections and require virtually no maintenance.

COST

As tube exchangers are larger for any given duty than a plate unit, the initial purchase price is usually higher. However, the lifetime cost must be considered as the PHE requires downtime and parts for maintenance. Another consideration is, are future changes in product possible? A food or beverage manufacturer may want to add fruit pieces for a new product range. These can only be heated or chilled through a tube heat exchanger.

So which heat exchanger is best?

It comes down to “horses for courses”.

Clear fluids such as milk, beer, and water are nearly always processed through plate heat exchangers and thick products or waste streams, including liquids with chunks or particles, and very high-temperature applications use tube heat exchanger designs.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Applications
  • Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • TERMS OF SALE
  • PRIVACY Policy
  • Products
  • Heat Exchangers
  • Processing Systems
  • Stainless Steel Fabrication
  • Service
  • Installation & Commissioning
  • Maintenance
  • Heat Exchanger Assessments
  • Dimple Technology

location

  • 15-19 Kialba Road, Campbelltown NSW 2560
  • AUSTRALIA
Request a Service or Parts for your Heat Exchanger
© Teralba Industries .   Designed & maintained by DigitL FX
Facebook-f Linkedin-in Youtube